Duplicate udids on emulators from different nodes

[Comeodore]

@saikrishna321
Android Studio and Genymotion can add on another PCs only same udids like on screenshot, can we do something to unify them/perceive them somehow differently so that you can interact with them normally
My task is that I need to collect all available emulators from all nodes

[saikrishna321]

Currently the screenshot shows all emulators collected from all nodes, As the udid are same across for emulators which may not be for real devices thats the reason we are adding node IP so its easy to identify the device.

We can also add another feature as node name which the user can provide and we can add that as well for easy identification.

Thoughts ?

[Comeodore]

easy identification

@saikrishna321 The problem is not so much in identification, but in the start of the driver, we only get to driver udid device in capabilities, will device-farm be able to manage sessions correctly to another emulators, but with the same udid?

[saikrishna321]

will device-farm be able to manage sessions correctly to another emulators, but with the same udid

What is the problem now?

We are handling it correctly when it comes to hub n node config thats the scenario when emulator will have same udid.

[Comeodore]

We are handling it correctly when it comes to hub n node config thats the scenario when emulator will have same udid.

@saikrishna321
No problem so far, I'm now more interested in how it works, cuz think u are not handling it, I'll test it tomorrow and let you know how its going for me

If I specify the judid emulator-5554, does the server select the first smallest by $loki device?

[saikrishna321]

Yes, it will pick the first free device matching the udid from one of the nodes and run the test.

[Comeodore]

Also, to distinguish between them, I use a notation like 'emulator-5554/10.18.141.163'

@saikrishna321 Can you do something like this or additional param to request?

[saikrishna321]

@Comeodore Please try the latest version 8.4.7-rc.5

You need to provide host: 'ip' in the capability

[Comeodore]

@saikrishna321 Hi, sorry for long answer


I think device-farm ignoring host param

[saikrishna321]

@Comeodore we have not tested with appium inspector.

Please share full server logs

[Comeodore]

@saikrishna321 tried with appium sessions - working fine, thanks
Appium inspector is not important for me

[truyenaspire]

I have issue related to Jenkin also.
In the same AWS machine, I can run mobile test in editor while connecting device-farm but I can't do it in Jenkin because error java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: org/openqa/selenium/remote/RemoteWebElement
Does someone have any idea? I also raise it at 978