diff --git a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/EditButton.tsx b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/EditButton.tsx
index 1f4d7d92..efaa5d84 100644
--- a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/EditButton.tsx
+++ b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/EditButton.tsx
@@ -5,13 +5,15 @@ type EditButtonProps = {
   buttonId: string
   buttonLabel: string
   onClick: () => void
+  isDisabled?: boolean
 }
 
 const EditButton = forwardRef<HTMLButtonElement, EditButtonProps>(
-  ({ buttonLabel, buttonId, onClick }, ref) => {
+  ({ buttonLabel, buttonId, isDisabled, onClick }, ref) => {
     return (
       <Button
         ref={ref}
+        isDisabled={isDisabled}
         id={buttonId}
         aria-label={buttonLabel}
         buttonType="text"
diff --git a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/NotificationForm.test.tsx b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/NotificationForm.test.tsx
index 72b9f198..ae0d93c5 100644
--- a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/NotificationForm.test.tsx
+++ b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/NotificationForm.test.tsx
@@ -1,7 +1,10 @@
 import { render, screen, fireEvent, waitFor } from "@testing-library/react"
 import { filteredPickupLocations } from "../../../../__test__/fixtures/processedMyAccountData"
 import { PatronDataProvider } from "../../../context/PatronDataContext"
-import { processedPatron } from "../../../../__test__/fixtures/processedMyAccountData"
+import {
+  processedPatron,
+  emptyPatron,
+} from "../../../../__test__/fixtures/processedMyAccountData"
 import { pickupLocations } from "../../../../__test__/fixtures/rawSierraAccountData"
 import SettingsSelectForm from "./SettingsSelectForm"
 import type { Patron } from "../../../types/myAccountTypes"
@@ -34,25 +37,71 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
     (pref) => pref.code === processedPatron.notificationPreference
   )?.name
 
-  const component = (
-    <PatronDataProvider
-      testSpy={accountFetchSpy}
-      value={{
-        patron: processedPatron,
-        pickupLocations: filteredPickupLocations,
-      }}
-    >
-      <SettingsSelectForm
-        patronData={processedPatron}
-        settingsState={mockSettingsState}
-        pickupLocations={pickupLocations}
-        type="notification"
-      />
-    </PatronDataProvider>
-  )
+  const processedPatronWithNone = {
+    notificationPreference: "-",
+    username: "pastadisciple",
+    name: "Strega Nonna",
+    barcode: "23333121538324",
+    formattedBarcode: "2 3333 12153 8324",
+    expirationDate: "March 28, 2025",
+    emails: ["streganonna@gmail.com", "spaghettigrandma@gmail.com"],
+    phones: [
+      {
+        number: "123-456-7890",
+        type: "t",
+      },
+    ],
+    homeLibrary: { code: "sn   ", name: "SNFL (formerly Mid-Manhattan)" },
+    id: 6742743,
+  } as Patron
+
+  const processedPatronWithNothing = {
+    notificationPreference: "-",
+    username: "pastadisciple",
+    name: "Strega Nonna",
+    barcode: "23333121538324",
+    formattedBarcode: "2 3333 12153 8324",
+    expirationDate: "March 28, 2025",
+    emails: [],
+    phones: [],
+    homeLibrary: { code: "sn   ", name: "SNFL (formerly Mid-Manhattan)" },
+    id: 6742743,
+  } as Patron
+
+  const processedPatronWithNoPhone = {
+    notificationPreference: "-",
+    username: "pastadisciple",
+    name: "Strega Nonna",
+    barcode: "23333121538324",
+    formattedBarcode: "2 3333 12153 8324",
+    expirationDate: "March 28, 2025",
+    emails: ["streganonna@gmail.com", "spaghettigrandma@gmail.com"],
+    phones: [],
+    homeLibrary: { code: "sn   ", name: "SNFL (formerly Mid-Manhattan)" },
+    id: 6742743,
+  } as Patron
+
+  const component = (patron) => {
+    return (
+      <PatronDataProvider
+        testSpy={accountFetchSpy}
+        value={{
+          patron: patron,
+          pickupLocations: filteredPickupLocations,
+        }}
+      >
+        <SettingsSelectForm
+          patronData={patron}
+          settingsState={mockSettingsState}
+          pickupLocations={pickupLocations}
+          type="notification"
+        />
+      </PatronDataProvider>
+    )
+  }
 
   it("renders correctly with initial preference", () => {
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatron))
 
     expect(screen.getByText(processedPatronPref)).toBeInTheDocument()
 
@@ -60,7 +109,7 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
   })
 
   it("allows editing when edit button is clicked", () => {
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatron))
     fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
 
     expect(
@@ -78,7 +127,7 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
   })
 
   it("manages focus", async () => {
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatron))
     fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
 
     await waitFor(() => expect(screen.getByRole("combobox")).toHaveFocus())
@@ -90,8 +139,36 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
     )
   })
 
+  it("disables editing the none preference when user has no phone or email", () => {
+    render(component(processedPatronWithNothing))
+
+    expect(screen.getByLabelText("Edit notification")).toBeInTheDocument()
+
+    expect(screen.getByLabelText("Edit notification")).toBeDisabled()
+
+    expect(screen.getByText("None")).toBeInTheDocument()
+
+    expect(
+      screen.getByText(
+        "Please set a phone number or email address to choose a notification preference."
+      )
+    ).toBeInTheDocument()
+  })
+
+  it("disables the corresponding dropdown field when user doesn't have that contact method", () => {
+    render(component(processedPatronWithNoPhone))
+
+    fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
+
+    const phoneOption = screen.getByRole("option", { name: "Phone" })
+    expect(phoneOption).toBeDisabled()
+
+    const emailOption = screen.getByRole("option", { name: "Email" })
+    expect(emailOption).not.toBeDisabled()
+  })
+
   it("calls submit with valid data", async () => {
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatron))
 
     fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
 
@@ -116,40 +193,7 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
   })
 
   it("displays none as an option if that's already user's selection", async () => {
-    const processedPatronWithNone = {
-      notificationPreference: "-",
-      username: "pastadisciple",
-      name: "Strega Nonna",
-      barcode: "23333121538324",
-      formattedBarcode: "2 3333 12153 8324",
-      expirationDate: "March 28, 2025",
-      emails: ["streganonna@gmail.com", "spaghettigrandma@gmail.com"],
-      phones: [
-        {
-          number: "123-456-7890",
-          type: "t",
-        },
-      ],
-      homeLibrary: { code: "sn   ", name: "SNFL (formerly Mid-Manhattan)" },
-      id: 6742743,
-    } as Patron
-    const component = (
-      <PatronDataProvider
-        testSpy={accountFetchSpy}
-        value={{
-          patron: processedPatronWithNone,
-          pickupLocations: filteredPickupLocations,
-        }}
-      >
-        <SettingsSelectForm
-          patronData={processedPatronWithNone}
-          settingsState={mockSettingsState}
-          pickupLocations={pickupLocations}
-          type="notification"
-        />
-      </PatronDataProvider>
-    )
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatronWithNone))
 
     fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
 
@@ -157,7 +201,7 @@ describe("notification preference form", () => {
   })
 
   it("cancels editing and reverts state", () => {
-    render(component)
+    render(component(processedPatron))
 
     fireEvent.click(screen.getByRole("button", { name: /edit/i }))
 
diff --git a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsInputForm.tsx b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsInputForm.tsx
index 7fa483f4..e6a8d7c9 100644
--- a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsInputForm.tsx
+++ b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsInputForm.tsx
@@ -251,7 +251,7 @@ const SettingsInputForm = ({
               <div style={{ width: "72px" }}> </div>
             </Flex>
           </Flex>
-        ) : isEmail || tempInputs.length !== 0 ? (
+        ) : tempInputs.length !== 0 ? (
           <Flex
             marginLeft={{ base: "m", lg: "unset" }}
             flexDir="row"
@@ -292,7 +292,6 @@ const SettingsInputForm = ({
                 onClick={() => {
                   setIsEditing(true)
                   setEditingField(inputType)
-                  console.log("hello")
                   setTimeout(() => focusFirstInput(), 0)
                 }}
               />
@@ -300,15 +299,17 @@ const SettingsInputForm = ({
           </Flex>
         ) : (
           // User has no phone or email.
-          <AddButton
-            inputType={inputType}
-            onClick={() => {
-              setIsEditing(true)
-              setEditingField(inputType)
-              handleAdd()
-            }}
-            label={formUtils.addButtonLabel}
-          />
+          <Box sx={{ marginTop: { base: "unset", lg: "-xs" } }}>
+            <AddButton
+              inputType={inputType}
+              onClick={() => {
+                setIsEditing(true)
+                setEditingField(inputType)
+                handleAdd()
+              }}
+              label={formUtils.addButtonLabel}
+            />
+          </Box>
         )}
 
         {isEditing && (
diff --git a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsSelectForm.tsx b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsSelectForm.tsx
index a1e8e9dc..40316052 100644
--- a/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsSelectForm.tsx
+++ b/src/components/MyAccount/Settings/SettingsSelectForm.tsx
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 import { useContext, useRef, useState } from "react"
 import { PatronDataContext } from "../../../context/PatronDataContext"
 import {
+  Banner,
   Flex,
   Select,
   SkeletonLoader,
@@ -33,17 +34,20 @@ const SettingsSelectForm = ({
   const selectRef = useRef<HTMLSelectElement | null>()
   const editingRef = useRef<HTMLButtonElement | null>()
 
-  const notificationPreferenceMap =
-    patronData.notificationPreference === "-"
-      ? [
-          { code: "z", name: "Email" },
-          { code: "p", name: "Phone" },
-          { code: "-", name: "None" },
-        ]
-      : [
-          { code: "z", name: "Email" },
-          { code: "p", name: "Phone" },
-        ]
+  const patronHasNonePref = patronData.notificationPreference === "-"
+  const patronHasPhone = patronData.phones.length > 0
+  const patronHasEmail = patronData.emails.length > 0
+
+  const notificationPreferenceMap = patronHasNonePref
+    ? [
+        { code: "z", name: "Email" },
+        { code: "p", name: "Phone" },
+        { code: "-", name: "None" },
+      ]
+    : [
+        { code: "z", name: "Email" },
+        { code: "p", name: "Phone" },
+      ]
 
   const sortedPickupLocations = [
     patronData.homeLibrary,
@@ -174,7 +178,14 @@ const SettingsSelectForm = ({
               value={tempSelection}
             >
               {formUtils.options.map((option, index) => (
-                <option key={`${type}-option-${index}`} value={option.name}>
+                <option
+                  key={`${type}-option-${index}`}
+                  value={option.name}
+                  disabled={
+                    (option.name === "Email" && !patronHasEmail) ||
+                    (option.name === "Phone" && !patronHasPhone)
+                  }
+                >
                   {option.name}
                 </option>
               ))}
@@ -182,17 +193,37 @@ const SettingsSelectForm = ({
           </Flex>
         ) : (
           <Flex marginLeft={{ base: "m", lg: "unset" }}>
-            <Text
-              sx={{
-                marginTop: { base: "xs", lg: "unset" },
-                width: { base: "200px", sm: "250px" },
-                marginBottom: 0,
-              }}
-            >
-              {selection}
-            </Text>
+            <Flex flexDir="column">
+              <Text
+                sx={{
+                  marginTop: { base: "xs", lg: "unset" },
+                  width: { base: "200px", sm: "250px" },
+                  marginBottom: 0,
+                }}
+              >
+                {selection}
+              </Text>
+              {type === "notification" &&
+                patronHasNonePref &&
+                !patronHasPhone &&
+                !patronHasEmail && (
+                  <Banner
+                    sx={{
+                      marginTop: "s",
+                      width: { base: "200px", sm: "250px" },
+                    }}
+                    content="Please set a phone number or email address to choose a notification preference."
+                  />
+                )}
+            </Flex>
             {editingField === "" && (
               <EditButton
+                isDisabled={
+                  type === "notification" &&
+                  patronHasNonePref &&
+                  !patronHasPhone &&
+                  !patronHasEmail
+                }
                 ref={editingRef}
                 buttonLabel={`Edit ${type}`}
                 buttonId={`edit-${type}-button`}