Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Problem with entering certain incidence algebras #63

Open
Nakayamaalgebra opened this issue Dec 13, 2021 · 1 comment
Open

Problem with entering certain incidence algebras #63

Nakayamaalgebra opened this issue Dec 13, 2021 · 1 comment

Comments

@Nakayamaalgebra
Copy link

I enter incidence algebras in QPA as in the following example that works fine:
L:=[ [ [ "'x1'", "'x2'", "'x3'", "'x4'", "'x5'", "'x6'", "'x7'", "'x8'", "'x9'", "'x10'", "'x11'" ],
[ [ "'x1'", "'x2'" ], [ "'x1'", "'x3'" ], [ "'x1'", "'x5'" ], [ "'x2'", "'x4'" ], [ "'x2'", "'x6'" ], [ "'x3'", "'x4'" ],
[ "'x3'", "'x8'" ], [ "'x4'", "'x7'" ], [ "'x5'", "'x6'" ], [ "'x5'", "'x8'" ], [ "'x6'", "'x7'" ], [ "'x6'", "'x9'" ],
[ "'x7'", "'x10'" ], [ "'x8'", "'x9'" ], [ "'x9'", "'x10'" ], [ "'x10'", "'x11'" ] ] ] ];Temp:=[];for i in L do Append(Temp,[[i,Poset(i[1],i[2])]]);od;Temp2:=[];for i in Temp do Append(Temp2,[[i[1],PosetAlgebra(GF(3),i[2])]]);od;A:=Temp2[1][2];

However, for certain strange posets the same method gives an error as in the following example:
L:=[ [ [ "'x1'", "'x2'", "'x3'", "'x4'", "'x5'", "'x6'", "'x7'", "'x8'", "'x9'", "'x10'", "'x11'" ],
[ [ "'x1'", "'x2'" ], [ "'x1'", "'x3'" ], [ "'x2'", "'x4'" ], [ "'x2'", "'x6'" ], [ "'x3'", "'x4'" ], [ "'x3'", "'x6'" ],
[ "'x4'", "'x5'" ], [ "'x4'", "'x7'" ], [ "'x5'", "'x8'" ], [ "'x5'", "'x9'" ], [ "'x6'", "'x7'" ], [ "'x6'", "'x9'" ],
[ "'x7'", "'x8'" ], [ "'x8'", "'x10'" ], [ "'x9'", "'x10'" ], [ "'x10'", "'x11'" ] ] ] ];Temp:=[];for i in L do Append(Temp,[[i,Poset(i[1],i[2])]]);od;Temp2:=[];for i in Temp do Append(Temp2,[[i[1],PosetAlgebra(GF(3),i[2])]]);od;A:=Temp2[1][2];

@sunnyquiver
Copy link
Contributor

This seems to be a bug inside GBNP or in the way QPA communicates with GBNP. Inside QPA there is an alternative way of computing a Groebner basis of an ideal by the command HighLevelGroebnerBasis. This method was contributed by erich-9. Here is how you could use this:

  1. P := Temp[ 1 ][ 2 ]; in the second case,
  2. execute lines 527 -- 573 and 577 -- 590 in the file pathalgpredef.gi in the lib directory,
  3. execute grb := HighLevelGroebnerBasis( relations, KQ );
  4. execute I := Ideal( KQ, relations );
  5. execute GroebnerBasis( I, grb );
  6. execute A := KQ/I; this will produce a 60-dimensional quiver algebra.

There has also been earlier cases with possible bugs in GBNP and/or the way QPA communicates with GBNP. The way QPA communicates with GBNP is unfortunately not documented, so it is a black box. The dependency on GBNP are not present in QPA2.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants