Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Apr 11, 2019. It is now read-only.

WIS hindcast data for winds/waves (data source) #63

Open
birdage opened this issue May 15, 2014 · 19 comments
Open

WIS hindcast data for winds/waves (data source) #63

birdage opened this issue May 15, 2014 · 19 comments

Comments

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor

birdage commented May 15, 2014

WIS provides hindcast data for a large number of nodes (see image), i dont think this information is available in the catalog, it is however available on their website in txt format.

screen shot 2014-05-15 at 9 32 06 am

Extract from an available text file

Atlantic
61001_v01               MEAN MONTHLY                            MAXIMUM CONDITIONS AT HMAX
  YRMT   No.OBS       HMEAN      TPMEAN        HMAX         TP     WAVE DIR     WND SPD    WIND DIR
 198101    240         1.45        8.29        2.57       10.79        5.00        7.90       58.00
@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 15, 2014

@Bobfrat any thoughts?

@rsignell-usgs
Copy link
Member

Text files. Yeesh. Crying out for ingest to 52 north & SOS, no?

@kwilcox
Copy link
Member

kwilcox commented May 15, 2014

Do the local RAs have this data available in their SOS servers?

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 15, 2014

@kwilcox not sure, me and bob were chatting about data sources and this was one that came up that i dont think its available through the catalog

@rsignell-usgs would be good if we could get at them a different way, there is close to 2500 nodes and we wouldnt want to have to pull down every text file.

@emiliom
Copy link

emiliom commented May 15, 2014

I'm intrigued. I wasn't aware of these hindcasts, and don't recognize what "WIS" is. Can someone post a link or two to the data files and a description of WIS? Thanks.

@Bobfrat
Copy link
Contributor

Bobfrat commented May 15, 2014

http://wis.usace.army.mil/

US Army Corps of Engineers Wave Information Studies for hourly, long-term (20+ years) wave climatologies along all US coastlines.

@emiliom
Copy link

emiliom commented May 15, 2014

Thanks. It looks like a useful resource. I'll bring it up in NANOOS in our weekly call today.

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 15, 2014

@emiliom @Bobfrat i think im going to parse the resources and add them to the waves notebook.

@kwilcox
Copy link
Member

kwilcox commented May 15, 2014

Long term, we should think about adding connectors to this data in pyoos and sensor-web-harvester

@dpsnowden
Copy link
Contributor

Before you parse these send a note to Julie Thomas at SCCOOS. She's also the CDIP manager. I think she did something with this data.

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 15, 2014

@kwilcox that would be a good plan

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 16, 2014

@dpsnowden @emiliom i had some time last night so wrote a parser for the wis data, it captures all the station information and monthly mean/max points and stores it in a DB that can be queried. im going to drop Julie Thomas an email today when i have a sec.

http://nbviewer.ipython.org/github/birdage/system-test/blob/76315348f1678719b879aebea020fa4351a8c3e4/theme2_extreme_events/ioos_extreme_events_waves.ipynb

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 21, 2014

@dpsnowden do you have contact info for Julie Thomas

At the minute rather than the DB approach which is not very sustainable long term, we are looking at adding a collector to pyoos to handle wis requests, this has been created as an issue in pyoos

@robragsdale
Copy link

@birdage Julie Thomas' email is [email protected]

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 21, 2014

@robragsdale thanks!

@birdage birdage self-assigned this May 21, 2014
@dpsnowden
Copy link
Contributor

Please review the documenting issues section. I think it is more important to log this issue and move on than to continue to find clever work arounds. The project goals focus on identifying things like this and calling them out, rather than spending too much time making up for the deficiencies. A good outcome from this notebook would be a well documented issue saying something like:

  • USACE should consider publishing WIS data via a web service and then creating and registering a standards compliant metadata record in an agency metadata repository.

Then, we wrap up the notebook and move on to another topic. I don't think that having the plots on the notebook adds enough value to warrant you spending time on it.

@dpsnowden dpsnowden added this to the Post SIT Enhancements milestone May 28, 2014
@dpsnowden
Copy link
Contributor

I labeled this issue as wontfix and assigned it to the "Post SIT Enhancements" milestone to indicate it's not something we can do during this project but still needs to be done.

@kknee
Copy link

kknee commented May 28, 2014

Agree with the WIS strategy. Will document the notebook appropriately and will create a separate issue here without all this extraneous discussion.

However, let's not give up on waves entirely. At a minimum we can use CDIP stations for expanding the model-obs comparison note books. Also looks like a handful of west coast stations have enough data to continue the extremes notebook.

@birdage
Copy link
Contributor Author

birdage commented May 29, 2014

@dpsnowden @kknee regarding the WIS data, i actually wrote a pyoos wis extractor one evening last week, and it will be merged in to the main pyoos code when i do some tidy up.

link:
ioos/pyoos#33

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

8 participants