MGCP TRD 4.5.1 EmbankL MCC

[tdvorakcaci]

Describe the bug
EmbankL (DB090) MCC values are not preserved. Values lost with Hootenanny import. All MCC changed from "Unknown" to "Soil" and MCC changed from "Concrete" to "Unknown".

To Reproduce
MGCP TRD 4.5.1 data imported using Hootenanny and MGCP translation option. "Unknown" values while not desirable, are allowable.

Expected behavior
Preserve MCC attribution. Analysts should determine values.

Screenshots
N/A

Desktop (please complete the following information):
N/A

Smartphone (please complete the following information):
N/A

Additional context
N/A

[mattjdnv]

I will have a try with shapefiles but I'm not seeing this in the translation server. Splitting the output over multiple comments for readability.
This script: hoot:/home/dg/hoot/translations $ ./checkSingleFeature.js feeds attributes or tags to the translation server, translates them forwards and backwards looking for differences.

UPDATE: No change with shapefiles.

NOTE: I have Drop Defaults turned OFF.

DB090 Line with concrete
---------------
MGCP  DB090  Line
Raw: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"21","WID":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
In Attrs: F_CODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :21:
In Attrs: WID: :5:
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :concrete:
Out tags: width: :5:

OSM: {"embankment":"yes","material":"concrete","width":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type: Way
In tags: embankment: :yes:
In tags: material: :concrete:
In tags: width: :5:
TableName 0: LDB090  FCode: undefined  Geom: Line
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type: Way
Out attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
Out attrs: MCC: :21:
Out attrs: WID: :5:

Ogr: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"21","WID":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
In Attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :21:
In Attrs: WID: :5:
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :concrete:
Out tags: width: :5:

OSM: {"embankment":"yes","material":"concrete","width":"5"}
-----

[mattjdnv]

DB090 Line with unknown
---------------
MGCP  DB090  Line
Raw: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","WID":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
In Attrs: F_CODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: WID: :5:
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: width: :5:

OSM: {"embankment":"yes","material":"unknown","width":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type: Way
In tags: embankment: :yes:
In tags: material: :unknown:
In tags: width: :5:
TableName 0: LDB090  FCode: undefined  Geom: Line
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type: Way
Out attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
Out attrs: MCC: :0:
Out attrs: WID: :5:

Ogr: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","WID":"5"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
In Attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: WID: :5:
LayerName:   Geometry: Line  Element Type:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: width: :5:

OSM: {"embankment":"yes","material":"unknown","width":"5"}

[mattjdnv]

DB090 Area with concrete
---------------
MGCP  DB090  Area
Raw: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"21","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: F_CODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :21:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :concrete:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"yes","material":"concrete","transport:type":"pedestrian"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
In tags: area: :yes:
In tags: embankment: :yes:
In tags: material: :concrete:
In tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:
TableName 0: ADB090  FCode: undefined  Geom: Area
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
Out attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
Out attrs: MCC: :21:
Out attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
Out attrs: TRS: :9:

Ogr: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"21","OSMTAGS":"{\"area\":\"yes\"}","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :21:
In Attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Not used: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :concrete:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"yes","material":"concrete","transport:type":"pedestrian"}

[mattjdnv]

DB090 Area with unknown
---------------
MGCP  DB090  Area
Raw: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: F_CODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"yes","material":"unknown","transport:type":"pedestrian"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
In tags: area: :yes:
In tags: embankment: :yes:
In tags: material: :unknown:
In tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:
TableName 0: ADB090  FCode: undefined  Geom: Area
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
Out attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
Out attrs: MCC: :0:
Out attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
Out attrs: TRS: :9:

Ogr: {"F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","OSMTAGS":"{\"area\":\"yes\"}","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Not used: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :yes:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"yes","material":"unknown","transport:type":"pedestrian"}

[mattjdnv]

Adding more attributes.

DB090 Area with unknown and Embankment type
---------------
MGCP  DB090  Area
Raw: {"FIC":"2","F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: FIC: :2:
In Attrs: F_CODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :fill:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"fill","material":"unknown","transport:type":"pedestrian"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
In tags: area: :yes:
In tags: embankment: :fill:
In tags: material: :unknown:
In tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:
TableName 0: ADB090  FCode: undefined  Geom: Area
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type: Way
Out attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
Out attrs: FIC: :2:
Out attrs: MCC: :0:
Out attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
Out attrs: TRS: :9:

Ogr: {"FIC":"2","F_CODE":"DB090","MCC":"0","OSMTAGS":"{\"area\":\"yes\"}","TRS":"9"}
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
In Attrs: FCODE: :DB090:
In Attrs: FIC: :2:
In Attrs: MCC: :0:
In Attrs: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
In Attrs: TRS: :9:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Not used: OSMTAGS: :{"area":"yes"}:
LayerName:   Geometry: Area  Element Type:
Out tags: area: :yes:
Out tags: embankment: :fill:
Out tags: material: :unknown:
Out tags: transport:type: :pedestrian:

OSM: {"area":"yes","embankment":"fill","material":"unknown","transport:type":"pedestrian"}