diff --git a/continuous_integration/home/coder/.local/bin/run-test-or-analysis b/continuous_integration/home/coder/.local/bin/run-test-or-analysis
index 155288f61..4cdd4221c 100755
--- a/continuous_integration/home/coder/.local/bin/run-test-or-analysis
+++ b/continuous_integration/home/coder/.local/bin/run-test-or-analysis
@@ -22,8 +22,12 @@ run_test_or_analysis() {
             pytest
             ;;
         "mypy")
-            echo "Executing mypy..."
-            mamba install -y -n "${DEFAULT_CONDA_ENV:-legate}" mypy
+          echo "Executing mypy..."
+            # Keep mypy version identical to mypy version in .pre-commit.yaml. The only
+            # reason we don't read it directly here is because when this is run in CI, it
+            # is done on a job which does not checkout the repo (and hence cannot read the
+            # .pre-commit.yaml).
+            mamba install -y -n "${DEFAULT_CONDA_ENV:-legate}" mypy=1.5.1
             cd ~/legate
             mypy legate
             ;;
@@ -36,4 +40,4 @@ run_test_or_analysis() {
     return 0
 }
 
-(run_test_or_analysis "$@");
\ No newline at end of file
+(run_test_or_analysis "$@");