Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Error deleting PDRs when using PFCP in simulation mode (-simulate delete) #683

Open
gab-arrobo opened this issue Apr 7, 2023 · 14 comments
Open

Error deleting PDRs when using PFCP in simulation mode (-simulate delete) #683

gab-arrobo opened this issue Apr 7, 2023 · 14 comments

Comments

@gab-arrobo
Copy link
Collaborator

Inserting rules using the PFCP in simulation mode works as expected:

$ docker exec bess-pfcpiface pfcpiface -config conf/upf.json -simulate create
time="2023-04-07T02:23:19Z" level=info msg="{Mode:dpdk AccessIface:{IfName:access} CoreIface:{IfName:core} CPIface:{Peers:[148.162.12.214] UseFQDN:false NodeID: HTTPPort:8080 Dnn:internet EnableUeIPAlloc:false UEIPPool:10.250.0.0/16} P4rtcIface:{SliceID:0 AccessIP:172.17.0.1/32 P4rtcServer:onos P4rtcPort:51001 QFIToTC:map[] DefaultTC:3 ClearStateOnRestart:false} EnableP4rt:false EnableFlowMeasure:false SimInfo:{MaxSessions:1 StartUEIP:16.0.0.1 StartENBIP:11.1.1.129 StartAUPFIP:13.1.1.199 N6AppIP:6.6.6.6 N9AppIP:9.9.9.9 StartN3TEID:0x30000000 StartN9TEID:0x90000000} ConnTimeout:0 ReadTimeout:15 EnableNotifyBess:false EnableEndMarker:false NotifySockAddr: EndMarkerSockAddr: LogLevel:info QciQosConfig:[{QCI:0 CBS:50000 PBS:50000 EBS:50000 BurstDurationMs:10 SchedulingPriority:7} {QCI:9 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:6} {QCI:8 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:5}] SliceMeterConfig:{N6RateBps:500000000 N6BurstBytes:625000 N3RateBps:500000000 N3BurstBytes:625000} MaxReqRetries:5 RespTimeout:2s EnableHBTimer:false HeartBeatInterval:}" func=main.main file="/pfcpiface/cmd/pfcpiface/main.go:37"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:19Z" level=info msg="SetUpfInfo bess" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:767"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:19Z" level=info msg="bessIP  localhost:10514" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:771"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:19Z" level=info msg="create sessions: 1" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:72"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:19Z" level=info msg="Sessions/s: 170.485775348848" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:271"

However, when deleting the rules, there is a problem deleting the PDR entries (pdrLookup method failed...)

$ docker exec bess-pfcpiface pfcpiface -config conf/upf.json -simulate delete
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=info msg="{Mode:dpdk AccessIface:{IfName:access} CoreIface:{IfName:core} CPIface:{Peers:[148.162.12.214] UseFQDN:false NodeID: HTTPPort:8080 Dnn:internet EnableUeIPAlloc:false UEIPPool:10.250.0.0/16} P4rtcIface:{SliceID:0 AccessIP:172.17.0.1/32 P4rtcServer:onos P4rtcPort:51001 QFIToTC:map[] DefaultTC:3 ClearStateOnRestart:false} EnableP4rt:false EnableFlowMeasure:false SimInfo:{MaxSessions:1 StartUEIP:16.0.0.1 StartENBIP:11.1.1.129 StartAUPFIP:13.1.1.199 N6AppIP:6.6.6.6 N9AppIP:9.9.9.9 StartN3TEID:0x30000000 StartN9TEID:0x90000000} ConnTimeout:0 ReadTimeout:15 EnableNotifyBess:false EnableEndMarker:false NotifySockAddr: EndMarkerSockAddr: LogLevel:info QciQosConfig:[{QCI:0 CBS:50000 PBS:50000 EBS:50000 BurstDurationMs:10 SchedulingPriority:7} {QCI:9 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:6} {QCI:8 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:5}] SliceMeterConfig:{N6RateBps:500000000 N6BurstBytes:625000 N3RateBps:500000000 N3BurstBytes:625000} MaxReqRetries:5 RespTimeout:2s EnableHBTimer:false HeartBeatInterval:}" func=main.main file="/pfcpiface/cmd/pfcpiface/main.go:37"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=info msg="SetUpfInfo bess" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:767"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=info msg="bessIP  localhost:10514" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:771"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=info msg="delete sessions: 1" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:72"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="farLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"rule doesn't exist\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processFAR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:1159"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"failed to delete a rule\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"failed to delete a rule\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="farLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"rule doesn't exist\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processFAR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:1159"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"failed to delete a rule\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"failed to delete a rule\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=error msg="farLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:2  errmsg:\"rule doesn't exist\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processFAR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:1159"
time="2023-04-07T02:23:55Z" level=info msg="Sessions/s: 255.73112633961557" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:271"

And then, if the user wants to insert again the rules (i.e., ... -simulate create), the PDRs are not inserted

$ docker exec bess-pfcpiface pfcpiface -config conf/upf.json -simulate create
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=info msg="{Mode:dpdk AccessIface:{IfName:access} CoreIface:{IfName:core} CPIface:{Peers:[148.162.12.214] UseFQDN:false NodeID: HTTPPort:8080 Dnn:internet EnableUeIPAlloc:false UEIPPool:10.250.0.0/16} P4rtcIface:{SliceID:0 AccessIP:172.17.0.1/32 P4rtcServer:onos P4rtcPort:51001 QFIToTC:map[] DefaultTC:3 ClearStateOnRestart:false} EnableP4rt:false EnableFlowMeasure:false SimInfo:{MaxSessions:1 StartUEIP:16.0.0.1 StartENBIP:11.1.1.129 StartAUPFIP:13.1.1.199 N6AppIP:6.6.6.6 N9AppIP:9.9.9.9 StartN3TEID:0x30000000 StartN9TEID:0x90000000} ConnTimeout:0 ReadTimeout:15 EnableNotifyBess:false EnableEndMarker:false NotifySockAddr: EndMarkerSockAddr: LogLevel:info QciQosConfig:[{QCI:0 CBS:50000 PBS:50000 EBS:50000 BurstDurationMs:10 SchedulingPriority:7} {QCI:9 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:6} {QCI:8 CBS:2048 PBS:2048 EBS:2048 BurstDurationMs:0 SchedulingPriority:5}] SliceMeterConfig:{N6RateBps:500000000 N6BurstBytes:625000 N3RateBps:500000000 N3BurstBytes:625000} MaxReqRetries:5 RespTimeout:2s EnableHBTimer:false HeartBeatInterval:}" func=main.main file="/pfcpiface/cmd/pfcpiface/main.go:37"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=info msg="SetUpfInfo bess" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:767"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=info msg="bessIP  localhost:10514" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).SetUpfInfo" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:771"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=info msg="create sessions: 1" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:72"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:28  errmsg:\"failed to add a new wildcard pattern\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:28  errmsg:\"failed to add a new wildcard pattern\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:28  errmsg:\"failed to add a new wildcard pattern\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=error msg="pdrLookup method failed with resp: error:{code:28  errmsg:\"failed to add a new wildcard pattern\"}, err: <nil>\n" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*bess).processPDR" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/bess.go:849"
time="2023-04-07T02:24:25Z" level=info msg="Sessions/s: 297.9375570550422" func="github.com/omec-project/upf-epc/pfcpiface.(*upf).sim" file="/pfcpiface/pfcpiface/grpcsim.go:271"
@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented May 8, 2023

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@gab-arrobo
Copy link
Collaborator Author

@amarsri28 @sureshmarikkannu any comments about this?

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Jun 8, 2023

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Jul 9, 2023

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Aug 9, 2023

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@amarsri28
Copy link
Contributor

@gab-arrobo did you tried debugging this issue further in test mode. let me know i 'll assign it to you,

@github-actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 30 days and will be closed in 5 days. Comment to keep it open.

@github-actions GitHub Actions
Copy link

This issue has been stale for 120 days and will be closed in 15 days. Comment to keep it open.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@amarsri28 @gab-arrobo @sureshmarikkannu