Mandatory Attributes

[PrathibaJee]

The latest UML2YANG tool will include mandatory substatement to attributes that has "Multiplicity 1 + no default values defined".
The following attributes which are formerly optional will be changed to mandatory in the upcoming YANG.

Further , if an attribute is decided to be optional , we shall handle it in the pruning-and-refactioring of coreModel.

S.No	class / datatypes	attributes	mandatory	optional
1	global-class	uuid	X
2	local-class	local-id	X
3	name-and-value-authority	uuid		X
4	local-id-and-class	local-id		X
5		class-of-instance		X
6	profile	profile-name	X
7	logical-termination-point	ltp-direction		X
8	layer-protocol	termination-state		X
9		layer-protocol-name	X
10		lp-direction		X
11	layer-protocol-name-and-qualifier	layer-protocol-name		X
12	fd-port	role		X
13		fd-port-direction		X
14	forwarding-construct	layer-protocol-name	X
15	fc-port	is-internal-port		X
16		role		X
17		fc-port-direction		X
18	fc-switch	hold-off-time		X
19		prot-type		X
20		switch-selection-reason		X
21		wait-to-restore-time		X
22	casc-port	port-role		X
23	casc-port-role-properties	signalling-format		X
24		monitoring-details		X
25		control-details		X
26	name-and-value	value		X
27	clock	run-mode		X
28	equipment-structure	category		X
29	equipment-type	type-name	X
30		version	X
31		model-identifier	X
32	manufacturer-properties	manufacturer-name	X
33		manufacturer-identifier	X
34	holder-structure	holder-category		X
35		is-captive		X
36		is-guided		X
37		is-quantised-space		X
38	connector	connector-type		X
39		role		X
40		orientation		X
41		pin-layout		X
42	holder	occupying-fru	X
43		holder-location		X
44	position	relative-position		X
45	spatial-properties-of-type	height		X
46		width		X
47		length		X
48	operator-augmented-equipment-instance	asset-instance-identifier		X
49	thermal-rating	thermal-rating-name		X
50		maximum-temperature		X
51		minimum-temperature		X
52	power-rating	power-rating-name		X
53		power-rating-value		X
54	signal-property-rule	signal-property-name		X
55		signal-property-value-rule		X
56	metaclass-class	metaclass-class-name		X
57	external-managed-universal-id	manager-identifier		X
58		external-managed-uuid		X
59	installed-software-component	name		X
60		version		X
61	running-software-process	name		X
62		process-id		X
63		run-state		X
64		priority		X
65		invoking-user		X
66		invoking-command		X
67		time-invoked		X
68		description		X
69	file	size		X
70		checksum		X
71		last-modify-time		X
72	file-system-entry	local-name		X
73		path-name		X
74		create-date		X
75		is-read-only		X
76		is-hidden		X

[michbin]

Some of the listed attributes cannot be mandatory because

• they have a type which is incomplete (e.g. role, pin-layout);
• they are deprecated (e.g. hold-off-time, wait-to-restore-time);
• they are not provided by some devices (e.g. height, width, length, orientation);
• they cannot be supported by some devices (e.g. external-managed-id).

[PrathibaJee]

230620 CoreModelMandatoryAttributes.xlsx

[openBackhaul]

Michael is asked to fill in the optional column with "X".
Thorsten is asked to fill in the mandatory column with "X".

[michbin]

Filled/commented sheet:
230620.CoreModelMandatoryAttributes.MB.xlsx

[openBackhaul]

Decision during the 5G-xhaul call on 12th of July 2023:
The attributes of the CoreIM shall be complemented by mandatory = true statements according to the following list.

S.No	class / datatypes	attributes	mandatory	optional
1	global-class	uuid	X
2	local-class	local-id	X
3	name-and-value-authority	uuid		X
4	local-id-and-class	local-id		X
5		class-of-instance		X
6	profile	profile-name	X
7	logical-termination-point	ltp-direction		X
8	layer-protocol	termination-state		X
9		layer-protocol-name	X
10		lp-direction		X
11	layer-protocol-name-and-qualifier	layer-protocol-name		X
12	fd-port	role		X
13		fd-port-direction		X
14	forwarding-construct	layer-protocol-name	X
15	fc-port	is-internal-port		X
16		role		X
17		fc-port-direction		X
18	fc-switch	hold-off-time		X
19		prot-type		X
20		switch-selection-reason		X
21		wait-to-restore-time		X
22	casc-port	port-role		X
23	casc-port-role-properties	signalling-format		X
24		monitoring-details		X
25		control-details		X
26	name-and-value	value		X
27	clock	run-mode		X
28	equipment-structure	category		X
29	equipment-type	type-name	X
30		version	X
31		model-identifier	X
32	manufacturer-properties	manufacturer-name	X
33		manufacturer-identifier	X
34	holder-structure	holder-category		X
35		is-captive		X
36		is-guided		X
37		is-quantised-space		X
38	connector	connector-type		X
39		role		X
40		orientation		X
41		pin-layout		X
42	holder	occupying-fru	X
43		holder-location		X
44	position	relative-position		X
45	spatial-properties-of-type	height		X
46		width		X
47		length		X
48	operator-augmented-equipment-instance	asset-instance-identifier		X
49	thermal-rating	thermal-rating-name		X
50		maximum-temperature		X
51		minimum-temperature		X
52	power-rating	power-rating-name		X
53		power-rating-value		X
54	signal-property-rule	signal-property-name		X
55		signal-property-value-rule		X
56	metaclass-class	metaclass-class-name		X
57	external-managed-universal-id	manager-identifier		X
58		external-managed-uuid		X
59	installed-software-component	name		X
60		version		X
61	running-software-process	name		X
62		process-id		X
63		run-state		X
64		priority		X
65		invoking-user		X
66		invoking-command		X
67		time-invoked		X
68		description		X
69	file	size		X
70		checksum		X
71		last-modify-time		X
72	file-system-entry	local-name		X
73		path-name		X
74		create-date		X
75		is-read-only		X
76		is-hidden		X

[PrathibaJee]

Required changes are available in the tool.
(Reference : Open-Network-Models-and-Interfaces-ONMI/onmi-iisomi-xhaul-uml-yang#51)
Changes to the attribute layer-protocol-name-and-qualifier/layer-protocol-name is handled inside the UML2YANG tool.
Apart from this, other changes are handled in the pruning and refactoring section.

[openBackhaul]

Implemented as decided.