Note dump contains comments made by deleted users (unlike API)

[matkoniecz]

note dump has comments from uid 1571629 on https://api.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/notes/8890.json shown in API as empty

Note, this is distinct from 500 error on viewing it via website ( openstreetmap/openstreetmap-website#2146 ) happening for all empty notes and therefore distinct from openstreetmap/operations#1014 .

I am reporting this as apparently redacted/deleted info persists in note dump - is it applying also for something more important?

See also https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/zombie-note-empty-in-api-comments-visible-in-note-dump/107122 where I tried asking. I also tried deleting all old note dumps and recheck I download recent one.

[tomhughes]

Moving to the correct repository.

[tomhughes]

This is actually the same as the 500 issue despite what you say - none of the note comments have been hidden but the user account that made them has been deleted.

I don't think this is resolvable until we determine what the correct behaviour is for deleted users which is currently an open question on the web site repository.

[matkoniecz]

changing then name to less confused one