diff --git a/src/Scarf/Gateway/Rule.hs b/src/Scarf/Gateway/Rule.hs
index 9209d34..31000e7 100644
--- a/src/Scarf/Gateway/Rule.hs
+++ b/src/Scarf/Gateway/Rule.hs
@@ -846,7 +846,7 @@ matchPixel PixelRule {..} Request {requestWai}
   | otherwise =
       pure Nothing
 
--- | Match a catch-all rule. In its current form the only thing it does is redirect a request 
+-- | Match a catch-all rule. In its current form the only thing it does is redirect a request
 -- to separate domain. Something that, in the past, has been done using file rules and catch-all
 -- patterns like /{+path}. While effective URI templates are not great at dealing with encoding
 -- specifics.
@@ -861,9 +861,7 @@ matchCatchAllV1 CatchAllRuleV1 {..} Request {requestWai}
       let !absoluteUrl =
             LBS.toStrict $
               toLazyByteString $
-                -- Just using the protocol that the request came in with 
-                -- allows for convenient testing.
-                (if Wai.isSecure requestWai then "https://" else "http://")
+                "https://"
                   <> Text.encodeUtf8Builder targetDomain
                   <> (
                        -- We would just like to use encodePath which is provided by http-types
diff --git a/test/golden/catch-all-1.output.yaml b/test/golden/catch-all-1.output.yaml
index b6a0344..575f8d0 100644
--- a/test/golden/catch-all-1.output.yaml
+++ b/test/golden/catch-all-1.output.yaml
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
 capture: |-
   Just
     FlatfileCapture
-      { fileAbsoluteUrl = Just "http://downloads.test.sh/hello%20world"
+      { fileAbsoluteUrl = Just "https://downloads.test.sh/hello%20world"
       , fileVariables = fromList []
       , filePackage = "8717953c-3452-4ef7-9a14-b64dc19163b4"
       }
 headers:
-  Location: http://downloads.test.sh/hello%20world
+  Location: https://downloads.test.sh/hello%20world
 status: 302
diff --git a/test/golden/catch-all-2.output.yaml b/test/golden/catch-all-2.output.yaml
index 0026b93..0eb1002 100644
--- a/test/golden/catch-all-2.output.yaml
+++ b/test/golden/catch-all-2.output.yaml
@@ -2,11 +2,11 @@ capture: |-
   Just
     FlatfileCapture
       { fileAbsoluteUrl =
-          Just "http://downloads.test.sh/search?q=hello%20world"
+          Just "https://downloads.test.sh/search?q=hello%20world"
       , fileVariables = fromList []
       , filePackage = "8717953c-3452-4ef7-9a14-b64dc19163b4"
       }
 headers:
-  Location: http://downloads.test.sh/search?q=hello%20world
+  Location: https://downloads.test.sh/search?q=hello%20world
 query: ?q=hello%20world
 status: 302