Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Z-Top Idlers #1054

Closed
wants to merge 20 commits into from
Closed

Z-Top Idlers #1054

wants to merge 20 commits into from

Conversation

Itzo1978
Copy link
Contributor

What mods has this PR added?

Replacing the original Z Idlers with my model

How has it been tested?

It was tested on my machine, the Voron 2.4 (v2.3941)

Any context you wish to provide?

I noticed a deformation of the belts. It's moving forwards causing the belt to be a few millimetres out of alignment. Consequence: the Z height cannot be respected without a correction in klipper (with distance_rotation)

My model makes it possible to correct this phenomenon

Tightening the screw from above to tighten the belt is much easier than from below.

Screenshots (if appropriate)

in progress

⚠️⚠️PLEASE READ AND COMPLETE THE CHECKLIST BELOW⚠️⚠️

  • I have read the rules available here and
    my mod adheres to these rules.
  • This mod was created by myself and I agree to publish it under the repository
    license

@jontek2
Copy link
Collaborator

jontek2 commented Sep 22, 2024

Hey @Itzo1978,

Looks like the bot has spotted issues with the metadata file. Seems like it contains unwanted characters.

I also noted that you uploaded 3mf files, but in the metadata refer to them as stl's. Could you change them to stls?

@Itzo1978
Copy link
Contributor Author

Itzo1978 commented Sep 22, 2024 via email

@jontek2
Copy link
Collaborator

jontek2 commented Sep 22, 2024

@Itzo1978 As i was typing i saw that you pushed some changes, hehe.

Seems like there's still a typo with "cad :" where it should be "cad:". I'll run the bot and see if there's any other changes needed aswell.

@Itzo1978
Copy link
Contributor Author

Itzo1978 commented Sep 22, 2024 via email

@jontek2
Copy link
Collaborator

jontek2 commented Sep 22, 2024

No worries, we'll figure it out.

I belive you have some naming issues with your files vs the yml file. If you look at the yml file it says:

cad:

  • CAD/[a]_z-top_tensioner_9mm_x4.step
  • CAD/z-top_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.step
  • CAD/z-top_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.step

Where the actual filenames are:

CAD/[a]_ztop_tensioner_9mm_x4.step
CAD/ztop_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.step
CAD/ztop_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.step

Please update this and i'll run the bot again.

@Itzo1978
Copy link
Contributor Author

Itzo1978 commented Sep 22, 2024 via email

Copy link

Hi, thank you for submitting your PR.
Please find below the results of the automated PR checker:

Added/Changed mods detected in this PR:

Item Result Description/Error Printer compatibility/Error Detail
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers ✅ SUCCESS Z-axis tensioner tightened from above, with the screw aligned with... V2.4r2

Tool check results overview:

Tool ⚠️ 💀
File checker 12
Readme generator 1
STL corruption checker 3
STL rotation checker 3
Mod structure checker

Tool check results details:

SUCCESS: ✅

File checker

Item Result Reason
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/README.md ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/.metadata.yml ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/CAD/ztop_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.step ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/CAD/[a]_ztop_tensioner_9mm_x4.step ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/CAD/ztop_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.step ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/STL/ztop_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/STL/ztop_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/STL/[a]_ztop_tensioner_9mm_x4.stl ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/Images/ZTop_Idlers_coupe.png ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/Images/ZTop_Idlers.png ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/Images/Z_Idlers_original.png ✅ SUCCESS
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers/Images/Z_Idlers_coupe.png ✅ SUCCESS

Readme generator

Item Result Description/Error Printer compatibility/Error Detail
Itzo1978/Z-Top_Idlers ✅ SUCCESS Z-axis tensioner tightened from above, with the screw aligned with... V2.4r2

STL corruption checker

Item Result Number of STL fixes applicable
ztop_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS 0
ztop_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS 0
[a]_ztop_tensioner_9mm_x4.stl ✅ SUCCESS 0

STL rotation checker

Item Result Original orientation Suggested orientation
[a]_ztop_tensioner_9mm_x4.stl ✅ SUCCESS
ztop_tensioner_bracket_a_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS
ztop_tensioner_bracket_b_x2.stl ✅ SUCCESS


I am a 🤖, this comment was generated automatically!

Made with ❤️ by the VoronDesign GitHub Team

@jontek2
Copy link
Collaborator

jontek2 commented Sep 24, 2024

Hey @Itzo1978 ,

After internal discussion and review, we've decided to reject this mod submission as it does not meet our submission rules, specifically the "Mods must not represent slight modifications of existing mods/existing VoronDesign printer parts."

However, you're more than welcome to upload it to platforms like Printables or other 3D model databases.

If you have any questions, feel free to reach out to us on Discord.

@jontek2 jontek2 closed this Sep 24, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants