Create and mount block devices efficiently served by static HTTP

This toolset allows you to create a chunked representation of a block device. The chunks can be uploaded to any static web server to form a repository. A client side tool can import from this repository and expose the content as a local block device using NBD so you can mount it readonly into the local filesystem.

The chunked representation uses content based hashing and encryption. Without knowledge of the 'UnlockKey', the files provide no insight other than what can be observed by their size and access pattern.

The repository can be easily validated using sha256sum and all filenames correspond to their SHA256 checksum.

Chunking of a block device can be repeated and the chunks can be placed in the same repository. When possible, chunks are reused and compressed. Mixing multiple block devices in the same repository is also possible.

Example: Importing content to a repository

Create an empty filesystem image:

user:/tmp$ truncate demo.img --size 50M
user:/tmp$ mkfs.ext4 -b 4096 demo.img
[...]
Creating journal (1024 blocks): done
Writing superblocks and filesystem accounting information: done
user:/tmp$ _

Optionally now mount as loop back and put files on it and unmount again. Then use the nbd-chunk-import tool to split up the demo.img file into chunks:

user:/tmp$ nbd-chunk-import demo.img UnlockKey RepoKey /tmp/chunks
543.0MB/s: 50MB => 0MB - 99.54% compression, 98.23% chunk reuse, 0.00MB new

f2f4fc043b7df808e68fe928ebaee54e2326e01d62e6e05617b4519c74da91ff#UnlockKey
user:/tmp$ _

This has converted demo.img into chunks and placed them into the specified target directory. Note that last line of output above. It will be needed to access the data later. UnlockKey and RepoKey must be replaced with real password-like value. This will be described down below.

First the output of the chunking. An empty ext4 filesystem is pretty easy to compress:

user:/tmp$ ls -l chunks/
total 20
-rw------- 1 user user 1830 Apr  1 23:23 145d9e19d411<truncated>
-rw------- 1 user user 1222 Apr  1 23:23 41cd84895c49<truncated>
-rw------- 1 user user 1206 Apr  1 23:23 c77b1e1ea5df<truncated>
-rw------- 1 user user  230 Apr  1 23:23 cdf67053231c<truncated>
-rw------- 1 user user  134 Apr  1 23:23 f2f4fc043b7d<truncated>
user:/tmp$ _

The files in chunks can now be placed on any static web server. Using rsync might be recommended as it can avoid copying already existing files in case the target web server already hosts chunks from a previous run.

user:/tmp$ rsync -av chunks [email protected]:
sending incremental file list
chunks/
chunks/145d9e19d411cb8eae559a8ff25c90a010da8d4f28fcb23be5651eece87e75cf
chunks/41cd84895c4949a85e20b6b028477a3a3290c58baf8ae199be5dd39e3291297e
chunks/c77b1e1ea5df6dcd9f6d89d5a2b3b0a41a268fd50f5aff44f7d858e013587c0a
chunks/cdf67053231c5947cab30fb48300aa8eff3f84a6b96f8c30a42d8c9bc17dec18
chunks/f2f4fc043b7df808e68fe928ebaee54e2326e01d62e6e05617b4519c74da91ff

sent 5,302 bytes  received 115 bytes  2,166.80 bytes/sec
total size is 4,622  speedup is 0.85
user:/tmp$ _

You can also verify that everything is content addressed:

user:/tmp$ sha256sum chunks/*
145d9e19d411cb8eae55<truncated>  chunks/145d9e19d411cb8eae55<truncated>
41cd84895c4949a85e20<truncated>  chunks/41cd84895c4949a85e20<truncated>
c77b1e1ea5df6dcd9f6d<truncated>  chunks/c77b1e1ea5df6dcd9f6d<truncated>
cdf67053231c5947cab3<truncated>  chunks/cdf67053231c5947cab3<truncated>
f2f4fc043b7df808e68f<truncated>  chunks/f2f4fc043b7df808e68f<truncated>
user:/tmp$ _

Repeat the chunking and uploading steps after making changes to the demo.img file or import additional block devices.

Example: Accessing the content of a repository

You'll need the intro URL to open an imported chunked block device. You can create that using the output of the nbd-chunk-import run above..

f2f4fc043b7df808e68fe928ebaee54e2326e01d62e6e05617b4519c74da91ff#UnlockKey

Prefix that value with the public URL base path where your HTTP server exports your chunk files. A full intro URL might look like this:

https://repo.example.com/f2f4fc043<truncated>c74da91ff#UnlockKey

The nbd-chunk-connect tool opens this URL and exposes it to the specified NBD /dev entry:

user:/tmp$ nbd-chunk-connect /dev/nbd0 https://repo.example.com/f2f4<...>
[..output..]

After a moment, the block device will be ready. See dmesg:

[ 6505.771400] nbd0: detected capacity change from 0 to 102400

(102400 * 512 sector size = 50MB) You can now mount the block device in another terminal. The 'ro' makes it explicit that the device will be read-only. Behold the almost empty filesystem:

user:/tmp$ mount /dev/nbd0 /mnt/demo -o ro
user:/tmp$ ls -l /mnt/demo
total 16
drwx------ 2 root root 16384 Apr  1 23:21 lost+found
user:/tmp$ _

UnlockKey and RepoKey

Both keys are intended for different use cases:

• The UnlockKey together with the SHA256 value of an intro chunk allows decryption of all referenced chunks required to access the complete chunkified block device. The intro URL above contains the URL of the intro chunk in the path component and the UnlockKey in the URL fragment.

  As long as users cannot list all chunks available on your repository web server, multiple UnlockKeys can be used to separate different version of a block device import while still allowing potential reuse for unchanged chunks.

  A value derived from the RepoKey is accessible to anyone with access to a intro URL as that is required to decrypt the referenced content.

• The RepoKey protects the content of all uploaded chunks against snooping by anyone controlling the HTTP Server. Without that key, none of the files are readable.

  As SHA256 named files will realistically never collide, multiple RepoKey values can also be used to scope different unrelated imports from each other.

This means:

• Once your share an intro URL (which includes the URL of the intro chunk and the UnlockKey) with other people, they will be able to fully access the content of the import that created the intro URL.

• If other people cannot list all files available, they will not be able to learn about other repositories based on them having knowledge of a single intro URL as guessing filenames is improbable.

• If all chunk files together with an UnlockKey leak, all imports using the same RepoKey will be accessible if the UnlockKey unlocks a single import.

• Unless the operator of the HTTP server has access to the UnlockKey, they will not be able to decrypt any of the content. They can only observe the access pattern and file size of individual chunks. They can also not modify any of the chunks as all their content is cryptographically hashed to ensure integrity.

• Due to the content addressing used, the operator of the HTTP server can verify the correctness of all chunk files by calculating their SHA256 sum and comparing it with the filename. Neither access to the UnlockKey or RepoKey is needed for that.

Architecture

All content of the provided block device is streamed into a chunk of fixed size. Once that chunk fills up (the default is 256KB), the chunk is wrapped up by first attempting to compress it using zlib, followed by encrypting it using a key based on its content and the derived RepoKey. It is then persisted and a new empty chunk as created. A reference to the persisted chunk (its SHA256 checksum) is added to the, potentially also newly created, chunk in the layer above. Similarly if the chunk in the layer above fills up, another layer is added on top of that, and so on.

Basically this forms a tree where each node has a vast number of childs (when using 256KB chunks, each chunk has 8192 child references). There is always only a single top level chunk.

As references use content based addressing repeated runs of single byte value all reference the same chunk. As a side effect, this also allows compressing those references. Similarly, new imports can reference chunks created by earlier imports assuming parts of the imported block device remain unchanged.

Special treatment is made to chunks that only contain zero-bytes. They will be completely skipped and the special 32 byte \x00 value is used as a reference. This also means that complete subtrees containing only zero bytes will be pruned completely. This allows efficient encoding of sparse files.

The top level chunk is referenced by the small intro chunk which provides some metadata about the import, like total size, number of layers and the derived RepoKey. The intro chunk is encrypted using the UnlockKey and persisted.

Then the SHA256 checksum of the intro chunk is printed together with the UnlockKey to access all that.

Notes

• This is the first release. All claimed cryptographic properties might be completely false due to design flaws. No promises are made. Feel free to provide feedback.

• I wrote this to see if its possible to mount a HTTP based, versioned and remote repository of my games stored on my MiSTer FPGA machine after my first SD card died.

• There is limited protection when accessing repositories created by malicious users. This is twofold:

  • The tool itself might now handle all edge cases if corrupt data is fed to it.

  • The resulting block device on /dev/nbdX can be dangerous to mount as filesystem code is complex and might not be hardened. You shouldn't trust the created NBD /dev entry more than a random USB stick you've found.

• As using nbd-chunk-import shares complete block devices, the usual caution is advised in regards to file deletion. shred with the -z flag (to help with compression) might help, but your mileage might vary.

• Somewhat related: For maximum compression, temporarily filling the mounted filesystem with zero-bytes prior to chunking it might be worth it. Of course that throws out all benefits of nbd-chunk-import sparse file support.

• If your filesystem image runs out of space, you can use truncate to extend the size of the image, then resize the filesystem. Sparse files take up no extra space on the disk and nbd-chunk-import knows how to compress them efficiently. The reuse of chunks should only add a few extra chunks as a result.

• Chunk downloads support redirects. This might allow some form of cheapo load balancing.

Out of scope

• Vastly different encryption methods or compression.

• Uploading to cloud targets. 'rclone' probably already solves that. But a custom ChunkWriter might implement throttling while writing out new chunks.

• Using external dependencies.

Ideas

• To get a first release done as a proof of concept, I wrote this toolset in Python over a weekend. It would be nice to have a more performant version in another language once the foundation is solid and it turns out to be useful.

• Background prefetching of chunks based on access patterns could speed up linear access. Although this might probably be already handled in some form in the kernel. Now sure..

• Right now only a small memory cache of chunks is implemented. This is probably good enough as the Linux buffer cache already caches repeated file access. It might still be useful to implement a file based cache to avoid repeated downloads if the same block device is mounted repeatedly.

  This could then even allow limited offline use as long as the access pattern remains the same.