-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 412
dev meeting 20190226
@ejgallego is working on adding support for building Coq projects with Dune. This requires some modifications to Coq itself but it is progressing.
https://github.com/ocaml/dune/issues/1855
Dune developers are generally happy with the proposal. @avsm mentions that plugins have been a failure in every OCaml tool and dune might know the same fate if we introduce plugins. On the other hand, there are enough compelling use case to justify providing some form of extensibility in dune. Using promotion to commit the output of plugins would leverage the issues, but we are not sure how bad it would impact their usability if we madee this the default, so we'll need to experiment.
We agree to go ahead with plugins, but make them an experimental feature at first.
@rgrinberg and @avsm mentions that there are a few additional features that are needed to make plugins cover the use cases we have in mind:
- the ability to specify stanzas for other directories, in particular generated ones. This is useful for ctypes
- some way to have automatic stanzas based on the contents of the
directory. For instance a way to say that every directory with a
run.tfile automatically gets a(dune_test)stanza, wheredune_testwould be defined by a plugin
We would like to provide better support for mdx in dune. Because mdx
files are often part of a library and share its build configuration,
i.e. in terms of dependencies and preprocessors, it seems natural to
add a field to the library stanza to allow specifying a list of .md
files that should be updated by runtest.
Sometimes these should also be part of the generated HTML documentation. We will need to figure out a way to specify this.
@avsm mentions that there is a similar question with odoc and code snippets in odoc comments. However, upstream is not decided on what to do so there is not much we can do on the dune side for now.
We have been discussin for a while the possibility of having configuration variables in dune. Mirage is likely to be the biggest consumer of this feature so configuration variables are currently being experimented with in the context of mirage.
The general consensus is that the status quo is acceptable, though it
does feel like it would be nice to have a mode in between release and
dev where we don't change the settings but still get the damn
executable even if the compiler has remarks about our code. Some kind
of dev-loose mode for instance. Better editor support would also
help in order to quickly switch between modes.