2024‐04‐19

DRAFT Meeting minutes April 10th 2024

Attending (11): Michael Gower, Alastair Campbell, Bruce Bailey, Patrick Lauke, Avon Kuo, Francis Storr, Giacomo Petri, Gundula Neiman, Mike Gifford, Dan Bjorge, Marco Sabidussi.

Lori Oakley.

Regrets: Scott O'Hara

We have a dozen items for approval by AG, due 4/29. Focus next week will use For Discussion column for feedback from AG.

Review Process document

Mike provided overview of updates to TF process and [Closing issues directly] (https://github.com/w3c/wcag/wiki/WCAG-2-Task-Force-process#closing-issues-directly) in particular. Feedback welcome.

Discussed Errata changes

Reflow discussion?

Review ‘For discussion’ items

Review ‘Drafted’ items (30 min), either:

move back to In progress, with more work to do

move to Ready for approval, if there is general agreement the issue is sufficiently resolved

leave in Drafted, if discussion was not concluded satisfactorily

Review issues closed

Review ‘To do’.

Time permitting, items of interest to participants, including open discussions.

---

Please be encouraged to assign yourself to Drafted item, and be prepared to walk group through the PR or proposed reply on a Friday call.

For discussion column review

• Update Input Purposes list to remove transaction-amount #3539 came up on Tuesday 4/9 AG WG call. No disagree about this being errata, but so might be subject to additional process review.
  • Mike pointed out that 2.0 has Glossary labeled as an Appendix, but then notes Glossary as Normative.
  • Alastair will be discussing with Kevin how to regain Appendix formatting.
• Merge pr3381 and pr3738 #3757 also highlighted on AG WG call. Not controversial, but many files involved and so few "thumbs up". TF members are asked to spot check!

Drafted column review

Moved to Ready for approval

• Mark input purposes list as non-normative #3778 has dependency on resolution of 3539 (above)
• Fixed typo on page #3693 technique H80
• Removing a defunct definition #3636 for "encloses" (from early draft for Focus Appearance)
• Fix to correct url #3697 in H33 to WCAG
• Fixed url typo for see also audio-only live #3774 in Understanding 1.2.1 Audio-only and Video-only (Prerecorded), the 1.2.4 reference should have been 1.2.9
• Fix typo in non-text-contrast.html #3705 rational -> ratio
• Aligned WCAG 2.2 with WCAG 2.1 - 2.5.5 Target Size (Enhanced) Understanding Doc (missing examples) #3638
• Update ARIA12 #3734 Note that numbering is confusable (12th ARIA technique for ARIA version 1.3). Also, as FS notes in thread, ARIA levels 10+ do not read correctly.
• Delete G187 and files that link to it #3736
• Change OL to UL when no order is intended (non-normative) #3518 Changing OL to UL where relevant. Need to check that it doesn't disrupt the build-process, particularly for the techniques. Otherwise ready for a reviewer, hopefully with a local build. First file, notes on conformance, might needs confirmation that it is in scope for TF.
• Removed H35 from 1.1.1 understanding doc #3779
• Does SC 1.2.1 require the alternative for time-based media for video-only to be visible? #3642 (Response only.) Bruce to clean up group proposed response and then move to Ready for approval.

Left in drafted

• Add sufficient technique for 2.4.7 using :focus-visible #3272 -- Requesting for feedback from Gundala or others.
• Editorial update to target size (minimum) exceptions #3189 touched upon, but time available was insufficient. Plan to revisit in meeting next week or the week after.
• Expand 1.4.10 Reflow note about 200% and breakpoints, add matching note to 1.4.4 Resize Text #2630 -- TF members, please review for next week!
• Change "mobile devices" to "smartphones" #3776 -- Group discussion favored making a proposed response rather than PR.

Open discussion